Skip to main content

5 most overrated WRs heading into the 2020 NFL season

Vincent Frank
New England Patriots WR Julian Edelman during NFL game against Titans
Jan 4, 2020; Foxborough, Massachusetts, USA; New England Patriots wide receiver Julian Edelman (11) points to the crowd before a game against the Tennessee Titans at Gillette Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Greg M. Cooper-USA TODAY Sports

We saw some young wide receivers break out big time last season. None more so than record-breaking New Orleans Saints pass catcher Michael Thomas.

On the other side of the ledger sits a group of big-name players at this position who are vastly overrated by the masses.

Is Cleveland Browns wide receiver Jarvis Landry worth his ridiculous contract? How will Julian Edelman perform without Tom Brady tossing him the rock? These are among the five-most overrated receivers heading into the 2020 NFL season.

Jarvis Landry, Cleveland Browns

The pure volume of targets makes Landry a realistic target in fantasy football circles. It also has many believing that the former LSU standout is better than he actually is. Landry has put up 2,150 receiving yards in two seasons with Cleveland after it acquired him from the Miami Dolphins. Not too shabby, right?

That’s until we realize that the high-priced pass catcher is averaging a mere 11 yards per reception and 7.2 yards per target throughout his six-year career. With Cleveland, Landry has also hauled in just north of 57% of his targets. That’s not much bang for your buck when it comes to a guy playing under a five-year, $75.5 million contract.

Alshon Jeffery, Philadelphia Eagles

A former Pro Bowler dating back to his days with the Chicago Bears, Jeffery signed what was then a mere one-year, $9.5 million deal with Philadelphia back in 2017. He ultimately gained less than 800 yards in 16 games with Philadelphia that season. For this, Jeffery was rewarded with a four-year, $52 million extension that December.

It’s been completely downhill since. The 30-year-old Jeffery is coming off an injury-plagued 2019 campaign that saw him record just 43 receptions for less than 500 yards. He’s caught less than 58% of his targets in three seasons with Philadelphia and is coming of a serious foot injury. At this point, Jeffery’s future in the City of Brotherly Love remains very much up in the air.

Julian Edelman, New England Patriots

A product of Tom Brady in New England? We’ll find out soon enough now that Brady is prepared to do his thing for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Sure this former Super Bowl MVP has put up stellar numbers for the Patriots after switching from small-school college quarterback to NFL wide receiver. Even then, he remains vastly overrated.

Edelman, 34, has never recorded more than seven touchdowns in any of his 11 NFL seasons. He’s gained 1,000 yards receiving just three times and is averaging a mere 7.2 yards per target throughout his career. Despite this, there’s been Hall of Fame talk surrounding Edelman. Come on.

Brandin Cooks, Houston Texans

Traded for a first-round pick twice and a second rounder once, it seems like the idea of Cooks is better than the reality. Otherwise, why would have three NFL teams already moved on from him in separate trades? It certainly is something to think about.

Last season with the Los Angeles Rams, Cooks recorded a mere 42 receptions for less than 600 yards in 14 games. It was the worst statistical output of his six-year career. He’s also scored a total of seven touchdowns on 189 targets over the past two seasons. Despite this, Texans head coach and general manager Bill O’Brien seems to think he can replace DeAndre Hopkins. That’s laughable.

Sterling Shepard, New York Giants

A former second-round pick out of Oklahoma, Shepard showed out big time in his first two NFL seasons, recording a combined 124 receptions for 1,414 yards and 10 touchdowns. He also caught 65% of his targets during this span. Most figured Shepard was destined for stardom, especially after the Giants traded Odell Beckham Jr.

It has not panned out. His splits are pretty much exactly the same over the past two seasons. Shepard is also coming off a 2019 campaign that saw him miss six games to injury. At this point, the receiver seems to be nothing more than a complementary piece for young quarterback Daniel Jones and Co.