Skip to main content

10 worst quarterback situations in the NFL

As NFL training camps inch closer on the calendar, it is fair to say that not every quarterback situation around the league is created equal.

Injuries of course play into the picture. Some of the league’s quarterbacks are looking to suit up and perform as if nothing ever happened after missing extensive time. In some cases, we shudder to envision these quarterbacks’ backups under center for any reason.

Outside of injuries, other quarterbacks will be playing behind shoddy offensive lines or even worse — reportedly sitting out due to a suspension.

With that said, here are the 10 worst quarterback situations in the NFL.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers

The Bucs look to be opening up the regular season without their starting quarterback, Jameis Winston, under center. He will reportedly be serving a three-game suspension for violating the NFL’s personal conduct policy. Further research into this story reveals Winston did not exactly keep very good company during the alleged event that led to the suspension.

This is definitely not a good look for a Buccaneers franchise that selected Winston first overall in 2015. Aside from this, Winston is coming off of a 2017 campaign in which he threw for only 19 touchdowns in 13 games. Veteran quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick, who completed just 58.9 percent of his passes when filling in for Winston last year, should be the face Bucs fans see when the season kicks off. Backing him up will be Ryan Griffin and rookie Austin Allen.

It is not even September, but it already looks to be an uphill battle for Tampa Bay.

Buffalo Bills

Where do we start? The Bills are once again conducting a quarterback competition to find out who is most qualified to open the season. This panel of quarterbacks consists of the newly signed A.J. McCarron, 2018 first-round pick Josh Allen and second-year passer Nathan Peterman. Despite the Peterman’s infamous five-interception game from last year, he is a “serious contender” to earn the starting job. He is reportedly out-performing McCarron, who struggled big-time in minicamp.

Beyond Peterman and McCarron, the Bills moved up in this year’s draft to select Allen seventh-overall. Though, head coach Sean McDermott has already said that Allen will begin training camp as the third-string quarterback.

The bottom line is, all of the above could see time under center this fall. Combined, the three quarterbacks have five pro starts, eight touchdowns and seven interceptions on record. It is no wonder we recently ranked the Bills’ offense as the league’s worst.

Cincinnati Bengals

Andy Dalton was brutal in Bengals shutout loss to Ravens.

It has been three seasons since quarterback Andy Dalton and the Bengals have made the playoffs. Last year in particular, Dalton looked out of sorts when he completed only 59.9 percent of his passes and threw for nearly 1,000 less yards than he did in 2016. Plus, his 25 touchdowns were muddied by 12 interceptions.

Outside of their down season, the Bengals failed to keep Dalton’s only viable backup — the aforementioned McCarron — on the roster. Sitting behind Dalton in depth is Matt Barkley, Jeff Driskel and rookie Logan Woodside. Should anything happen with Dalton this year, the Bengals would be hard pressed to impress with this supporting cast.

Circling back to Dalton, the Bengals are still holding out hope he’ll live up to his “elite potential.”

Seattle Seahawks

The Seahawks had better keep knocking on wood hoping Russell Wilson stays healthy. If anything were to go awry here regarding Wilson, the Seahawks would be toast. Working behind a Swiss cheese offensive line, Wilson has been sacked 248 times since he was drafted in 2012. That equates to an average of 41.3 sacks per year, which is a ridiculous stat.

Wilson is an exceptionally talented quarterback who should not be running around fearing for his safety each week. The Seahawks are very fortunate that Wilson has not missed one game out of 96 contests. Behind Wilson is second-year quarterback Austin Davis and rookie Alex McGough. The Hawks can only hope Wilson keeps remaining resilient to the physical torture he endures on a seasonal basis.

Indianapolis Colts

Whether Anfrew Luck returns to full health or suffers another setback will determine the Colts’ success for the foreseeable future. Reportedly, Luck is on course to open the season and hopefully ready to sling the pigskin like he did in his earlier years. But, what if he is not?

We all witnessed what it was like to watch Luck play at a limited capacity in 2015. That was the season he completed just 55.3 percent of his passes and threw 12 interceptions compared to 15 touchdowns in seven games.

Backup Jacoby Brissett remains on hand — just in case — as do Brad Kaaya and Phillip Walker. Yuck.

Dallas Cowboys

The Cowboys aren’t exactly a sure bet when it comes to the offense’s success behind quarterback Dak Prescott. Prescott was the prime example of a player stuck in a sophomore slump last year. He went from throwing 23 touchdowns and only four interceptions in 2016 to 22 touchdowns and 13 interceptions last season. Plus, Prescott’s pass completion rate dropped by nearly five percent.

It also does not help moving forward that Prescott is minus wide receiver Dez Bryant and tight end Jason Witten. If for some reason Prescott continues to regress, and the Cowboys are forced to explore other options, second-stringer Cooper Rush would be the next guy to call upon.

Hopefully, the Cowboys won’t have to turn to that drastic measure. Nevertheless, it is worth noting that Prescott has been undrafted in many early fantasy football mock drafts.

New York Giants

The Giants earned high marks from some by selecting running back Saquon Barkley second-overall in this year’s draft. With that choice, the Giants also passed on drafting an heir apparent to Eli Manning from this year’s class of top quarterback prospects, which earned our scorn. So for now, Manning it is.

The Giants can only hope Manning improves from last year’s performance with the healthy return of his No. 1 receiver, Odell Beckham Jr. If not, and if for some reason Manning were to get the hook like last year (or get injured), it would place Davis Webb under center. Behind Webb sits rookie fourth-rounder, Kyle Lauletta.

Whether Manning shines or burns this season, the Giants soon need to address their long-term quarterback needs.

Denver Broncos

The Broncos are placing a ton of faith in Case Keenum as the current face of the franchise. So much so that they passed on taking a top quarterback with their fifth-overall pick. After all, Keenum played extremely well in Minnesota in 2017 when he completed a career-high 67.6 percent of his passes. He also threw for 3,547 yards and 22 touchdowns.

But, what if Keenum stinks up his new digs? Prior to last year, Keenum produced a 9-15 record as a starter that was accompanied by 24 touchdowns and 20 interceptions. These stats are fresh enough to consider them somewhat of a red flag. Though, the Broncos seemingly trust Keenum to build on last season’s success. If for some reason the Broncos have to revert to backup Paxton Lynch, or Chad Kelly, selected in 2017, it will be time to panic.

Miami Dolphins

Ryan Tannehill Miami Dolphins

Speaking of panicking, the Dolphins thought it prudent to sign ex-Denver quarterback failure Brock Osweiler as depth behind Ryan Tannehill. Tannehill is expected to resume his starting role after playing 13 games in 2016 and missing the entire 2017 season.

The last time Tannheill was on the field, he averaged 230 passing yards per contest and threw 19 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. These are not exactly inspiring numbers to reminisce about. If injury should strike Tannehill again, the team would look to its other options including David Fales, who reportedly is the front-runner ahead of Osweiler.

And if worse comes to worse, Bryce Petty, originally drafted by the New York Jets in 2015, is also on hand. Yikes.

Tennessee Titans

Instead of improving in his third year, Mariota dealt with minor injuries and did not impress by any means last season. The Titans made the postseason, though Mariota looked nothing like a playoff-caliber quarterback much of the year.

He threw for a mere 13 touchdowns compared to the 26 he produced in 2016. Along with that, Mariota added a career-high 15 interceptions. This is somewhat worrisome heading into 2018.

The good news is, Mariota is reportedly faster now that he is not sporting his knee brace. All parties involved can only hope that Mariota is indeed ready to shed his slump. The options behind him, starting with Blaine Gabbert and rookie Luke Falk, are just a tad scary.

Mentioned in this article:

More About: