Skip to main content

3 reasons why a Gardner Minshew trade to the San Francisco 49ers makes sense

Vincent Frank

[brid autoplay=”true” video=”715554″ player=”23231″ title=”5%20San%20Francisco%2049ers%20trade%20scenarios%20for%20this%20offseason” duration=”88″ description=”We look at five San Francisco 49ers trade scenarios heading into the offseason as the team attempts to get back on track following an injury-plagued 2020 season.” uploaddate=”2021-02-05″ thumbnailurl=”//cdn.brid.tv/live/partners/17660/thumb/715554_t_1612560717.png” contentUrl=”//cdn.brid.tv/live/partners/17660/sd/715554.mp4″]

Ever since the Jacksonville Jaguars acquired the No. 1 pick in the 2021 NFL Draft, it seemed inevitable that they would look to move quarterback Gardner Minshew.

After all, new head coach Urban Meyer is ready to hand over the Duval kingdom to consensus top prospect Trevor Lawrence starting in 2021.

A potential Minshew trade has now become increasingly likely after Jacksonville signed former San Francisco 49ers third-round pick C.J. Beathard to a multi-year contract on Wednesday.

NFL Media’s Ian Rapoport reported that the Jaguars have had talks with other teams relating to the former sixth-round pick. Meanwhile, Jeremy Fowler of ESPN notes that the 49ers seem to be up to something at quarterback and could target Gardner Minshew.

“The 49ers are up to something at quarterback. They had extensive talks with (Joe) Flacco, who hit it off with Kyle Shanahan during a visit last week before ultimately choosing Philly,” Fowler noted. “Rumors persist that Jacksonville quarterback Gardner Minshew II could be in their plans via trade.”

Indeed. The 49ers did have Flacco in for a visit earlier in free agency prior to the Super Bowl quarterback signing with the Philadelphia Eagles recently. They were also in on Mitchell Trubisky before he opted to surprisingly sign with the Buffalo Bills.

Reports earlier in the offseason suggested that San Francisco was looking for an upgrade over injury-plagued and embattled starter Jimmy Garoppolo.

With the Deshaun Watson thing up in the air following numerous allegations of sexual assault, it now looks like San Francisco is attempting to find a quality backup behind Garoppolo. Here’s three reasons why a Gardner Minshew trade to the 49ers makes sense.

Read More: Gardner Minshew receiving trade interest from NFL teams, three potential destinations

Gardner Minshew is a cost-effective option for the San Francisco 49ers

Gardner Minshew trade to the San Francisco 49ers?
Dec 27, 2020; Jacksonville, Florida, USA; Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Gardner Minshew II (15) enters the field prior to a game between the Jaguars and the Chicago Bears at TIAA Bank Field. Mandatory Credit: Douglas DeFelice-USA TODAY Sports

49ers general manager John Lynch has done well to retain most of their core free agents despite a less than stellar cap situation heading into last week. That included handing Trent Williams the richest contract in NFL history for a tackle and signing Pro Bowl center Alex Mack.

Right now, the 49ers are an estimated $15 million under the cap after re-signing stud cornerback K’Waun Williams. With that said, they have pushed back against spending money on a backup quarterback behind Garoppolo. Flacco’s one-year, $4 million deal with Philadelphia adds to that belief.

As for Gardner Minshew, he’s a former late-round pick and remains under his rookie contract. That means any team acquiring the 24-year-old signal caller would be facing a combined $1.9 million cap hit over the next two seasons. For a 49ers team that needs money to find depth elsewhere, that’s an extremely valuable aspect to a potential trade.

Related: NFL mock draft 2023 – CJ Stroud, Bryce Young headline outstanding 2023 NFL Draft class

He’s the best remaining quarterback the 49ers could target

Deshaun Watson, San Francisco 49ers
Dec 20, 2020; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Houston Texans quarterback Deshaun Watson (4) during warmups before the game against the Indianapolis Colts at Lucas Oil Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Trevor Ruszkowski-USA TODAY Sports

San Francisco was previously linked to former New York Jets No. 3 pick Sam Darnold. It made some sense. Head coach Kyle Shanahan was enamored with the USC product leading up to the 2018 NFL Draft. Unfortunately, that came mere months after the 49ers traded for Garoppolo during the 2017 season. Darnold was not an option.

Unfortunately, it doesn’t appear he’s an option right now. The Jets have yet to decide whether to trade Darnold and go with Zach Wilson at No. 2 in the 2021 NFL Draft. Meanwhile, any team acquiring the struggling quarterback would be facing a spring deadline to pick up what would be a $25 million option on Darnold’s contract for the 2022 season. Given his performance, that makes no sense.

As for Deshaun Watson, San Francisco is one of a number of teams still interested in the reigning NFL passing champion. However, recent allegations from over a dozen women claiming sexual assault in civil suits changes the dynamics here. Simply put, it’s hard to envision any team dealing for Watson until that situation is resolved. All of this leads me to believe Gardner Minshew might be the 49ers’ best option.

Read More: San Francisco 49ers reportedly not expected to trade for Sam Darnold

Past success from Gardner Minshew and Jimmy Garoppolo injury issues

NFL power rankings: San Francisco 49ers
Nov 1, 2020; Seattle, Washington, USA; San Francisco 49ers quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo (10) returns to the locker room following pregame warmups against the Seattle Seahawks at CenturyLink Field. Mandatory Credit: Joe Nicholson-USA TODAY Sports

It’s fine to question Minshew’s raw talent. There’s a reason he was the 178th pick in the 2019 NFL Draft. There’s also a reason Jacksonville is moving off him for Trevor Lawrence.

That’s all fine and dandy. But the tape and his stats tell us a story of someone who could, at the very least, be a top-end backup in the NFL. Minshew accounted for north of 6,000 total yards with 38 touchdowns against 11 interceptions in 20 starts over a two-year span with Jacksonville. Can we possibly ignore those eye-opening numbers, especially given the lack of talent in Duval?

At the very least, Minshew is a better option than the recently-departed C.J. Beathard and an injured Nick Mullens. Heck, he has more of a proven track record in the NFL than a more-heralded former prospect in Josh Rosen. With Garoppolo having missed 23 of a possible 48 games over the past three seasons, adding Gardner Minshew to the mix would give San Francisco a ton of insurance on the cheap.