Friday’s Week 1 NFL preseason action didn’t feature a lot of star players, but as football fans, we watched anyway. The NFL fed us three games, and we brought our forks and spoons because, like you, we’re starved for football this time of year. But who were the biggest winners and losers from Friday’s action?
Loser: Miami Dolphins quarterbacks Skylar Thompson and Mike White
The Miami Dolphins have a QB competition brewing. But on Friday, it appeared neither of Tua Tagovailoa’s backups wanted the job. Skylar Thompson got the first crack, but he’d complete just 8-of-19 passes for 95 yards, including a touchdown and interception. Unfortunately, Mike White was even worse, completing 4-of-14 passes for a measly 26 yards. Making matters worse, White was even ‘credited’ with one fumble.
Related: NFL QB Rankings 2024: From Patrick Mahomes to Gardner Minshew
Winner: Jeremiah Trotter Jr, Philadelphia Eagles linebacker
Amazingly, Jeremiah Trotter Jr got drafted to the same team his dad played for. While Trotter Jr had to wait until the fifth round, unlike his father, who was a third-round pick, he’s already off to a good start. Trotter led the Eagles with six tackles, but he also added a sack and a QB hit. If he can keep this up, Eagles defensive coordinator Vic Fangio will have a hard time not finding a role for the 21-year-old rookie.
Related: Top-selling NFL jerseys 2024: Who has the NFL’s best-selling jersey?
Loser: Josh Johnson, Baltimore Ravens quarterback
The Baltimore Ravens may need a new backup quarterback. Josh Johnson, who’s played for 17 different teams, including those not in the NFL, is now 38 years old. His mobility makes him a good fit to be Baltimore’s backup in a scheme that takes advantage of Lamar Jackson’s game-breaking ability. However, Johnson still needs to play well. He didn’t on Friday. Johnson completed just 4-of-12 passes for 62 yards while adding 11 more yards on two rush attempts. It wasn’t a very inspiring performance for someone with eight years of NFL experience.
Related: NFL MVP odds 2024: Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, Joe Burrow start as favorites
Winner: Nate Wiggins, Baltimore Ravens cornerback
During the pre-draft process, Nate Wiggins was hyped as one of the best cornerbacks available. Somehow the blazing quick Clemson product slipped to pick No. 30, where the Baltimore Ravens ended his slide. Yet, on Friday, Wiggins justified Baltimore’s draft decision with an impressive drive that featured multiple pass deflections. He ended with three tackles, including a tackle for loss and three pass deflections.
Related: Predicting NFL playoff teams and Super Bowl 2025 winner
Winner turned Loser: Kyle Allen, Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback
Kyle Allen has been lurking somewhere around the NFL since going undrafted in 2018. He’s bounced around to five different teams now, but he was mostly impressive on Friday night in Pittsburgh. The 28-year-old wasn’t perfect; he did fumble once and he threw a game-sealing INT, but third-string quarterbacks often have rough patches. Yet, when Allen was on, he was quite good, completing 17-of-23 passes for 193 yards and a touchdown. This 38-yard find to Scotty Miller might have been his best play of the day. But then he ended it on a sour note with a sailed pass attempt that found Texans defender Brandon Hill for an interception.
Related: Super Bowl odds: Every team’s championship futures for 2024 NFL season
Loser turned Winner: Jake Elliott, Philadelphia Eagles kicker
Jake Elliott is one of the best kickers in the NFL, but he’s clearly not in mid-season form quite yet. The Philadelphia Eagles kicker uncharacteristically missed an extra point in Friday’s game, just his fourth one over the past three seasons. Elliott also missed a 50-yard potential game-winner off the right upright. However, his missed kicks didn’t matter, thanks to his game-winning 49-yard field goal as the clock expired following a strip-sack.
Related: 10 worst NFL starting quarterbacks right now, including Bryce Young
Winner: C.J. Stroud, Houston Texans quarterback
The Houston Texans’ franchise quarterback didn’t get to play much in his preseason debut. But he didn’t need to. Stroud, entering his second season, was sharp, completing 2-of-4 passes for 41 yards. But his best throw was a 34-yard touchdown strike to Tank Dell. The season hasn’t even started yet, but the Texans offense already looks ready to pounce.
Related: Who is the highest-paid NFL coach? (Today and All-Time)
Winner: James Daniels, Pittsburgh Steelers right guard
James Daniels isn’t on this list because of his play on the field. Instead, he’s a winner for becoming the first NFL player to wear a ‘Guardian’ cap on his helmet during a live game. Head injuries are nothing to play with, and by Daniels breaking a barrier, hopefully it encourages others to protect the most important part of their body. Players want to be on the field as much as they can, and by wearing an extra layer of protection, Daniels just increased his odds of avoiding injury.
Related: 10 worst NFL general managers in 2024, including Jerry Jones and Tom Telesco
Loser: Quez Watkins, Pittsburgh Steelers punt returner/wide receiver
Quez Watkins, in his first season with the Pittsburgh Steelers after four years in Philadelphia, didn’t make a good first impression during the preseason. It wasn’t due to his production, or lack thereof, as a receiver. He wasn’t even targeted once. Instead, it was due to a badly muffed punt that set the Texans up with favorable field position at the 30-yard line. Special teams miscues will get a player cut very quickly, especially since he’s already one of many receivers in a crowded Steelers depth chart.
Related: 15 longest field goals in NFL history, including Super Bowls
Winner: Michael Penix Jr, Atlanta Falcons quarterback
Michael Penix Jr.’s first chance to impress Atlanta Falcons fans went very well. Of course, this only increases the pressure on Kirk Cousins to have a strong start while recovering from his Achilles tear. Yet, it’s a positive sign that the Falcons may have their future franchise QB too. Penix completed 9-of-16 passes for 104 yards, including this 41-yard beauty to Chris Blair. The Falcons may have surprised everyone by picking Penix, but he’s doing his best to prove the doubters wrong.
Related: 10 NFL teams that will disappoint in 2024, including the Chicago Bears and Philadelphia Eagles