Last year, Buffalo Bills All-Pro linebacker Matt Milano was limited to just five games after tearing his ACL while suffering a fractured leg. This year, the 30-year-old has already suffered a torn pec, which could keep him out until December, if not longer. If Milano’s absence lasts that long, he’d miss the first 12 weeks of the season for a team that has playoff aspirations. Naturally, the Bills will need someone else to step up. Here are six possible solutions.
Sign David Mayo
There are better options available, but it all depends on how much the Buffalo Bills are willing to invest to replace Milano. If Buffalo prioritizes a low-cost addition, then signing David Mayo could be a fair solution. Mayo won’t be able to replace Milano’s production in pass coverage, but no one really can. He’s a veteran with nine years of experience, but the Bills may prefer to look elsewhere.
- David Mayo stats: 17 games, five starts, 59 tackles, 2 sacks in 2023
- David Mayo PFF grades: 73rd among LBs, 55.7 defense, 72.2 run defense, 75.3 pass rush, 38.3 coverage
Related: Where does Josh Allen land in Sportsnaut’s NFL QB Rankings?
Sign 4x Pro Bowl linebacker Anthony Barr
Anthony Barr is a four-time Pro Bowl linebacker who brings freakish 6-foot-5 size to the table. Now 32, Barr’s best days are likely behind him, and analysis from Pro Football Focus backs up that statement. He hasn’t had a PFF grade above 70 since 2018 (70.9). However, Barr has shown an ability to be good at everything, whether it’s in coverage, rushing the passer, or stopping the run. If the Bills think Barr still has more fuel in his tank, he could return to being an impact player, but we haven’t seen that version of the former first-round pick for several years.
- Anthony Barr stats (career): 554 tackles, 18.5 sacks, 5 INT, 8 FF, 32 PD
- Anthony Barr PFF grades: 59.5 defense, 61.6 run defense, 63.9 pass rush, 57.1 coverage
Related: Are the Buffalo Bills projected to make the playoffs this year?
Trade for Minnesota Vikings linebacker Brian Asamoah II
If the Bills are willing to part with a late Day 3 draft pick, they could turn to the trade market for an athletic former third-round pick who hasn’t lived up to his potential. Brian Asamoah II landed with the Vikings in 2022, but he’s never cracked the starting lineup, and he’s already been surpassed by former undrafted linebacker Ivan Pace Jr, plus 2024 signee and Minnesota native Brian Cashman. Asamoah may not have a future with the Vikings, but the Bills could buy low and hope for a rewarding outcome for a linebacker with 4.5 speed.
- Brian Asamoah stats (career): 29 games, 24 tackles, 1 FF, 1 FR
- Brian Asamoah PFF grades: 78.8 overall in 2022, 38.3 in 2023 – 50.9 run defense, 58.05 pass rush, 75.3 coverage
Related: 5 ideal Haason Reddick trade landing spots after New York Jets trade request
Sign Zach Cunningham
At 6-foot-3, 238 pounds, Zach Cunningham has great size. The 29-year-old’s best season came in 2020 when he led the NFL with 164 tackles. But Houston moved on from him the following season. Cunningham joined Philadelphia last season, but they’ve since found other solutions. Cunningham has never graded very positively per Pro Football Focus, but he’s a tackling machine who’s best work is likely as a run-stuffer.
- Zach Cunningham stats (2023): 13 games, 10 starts, 85 tackles, 4 PD, 1 FR
- Zach Cunningham PFF grades: 37th among LB, 67.6 defense, 71.5 run defense, 49.9 pass rush, 67.9 coverage
Related: Buffalo Bills schedule
Trade for Carolina Panthers’ Shaq Thompson
Shaq Thompson has spent his entire nine-year career with the Carolina Panthers. He’s still expected to start his tenth season, but the Panthers also drafted Trevin Wallace in the third round, meaning Thompson’s writing could be on the wall. Now 30 and in the final year of his contract, Carolina could view their 2015 first-round pick as expendable. He played just two games a year ago, but prior to that, Thompson had four consecutive seasons with 100 or more tackles. He’d be another low-cost acquisition, but could end up having a big impact on Buffalo’s attempt to get deep into the postseason.
- Shaq Thompson stats (2022): 135 tackles, 4 PD, 1 FF, 1 FR, 0.5 sack
- Shaq Thompson PFF grades: 72.3 defense, 90.3 run defense, 49.5 pass rush, 56 coverage
Related: Buffalo Bills Super Bowl odds
Sign 3x All-Pro Shaquille Leonard
In 2022, Shaquille Leonard landed 18th on the NFL’s annual top-100 players list. But an offseason back surgery has seemingly sapped Leonard’s ability to play at a high level. Leonard was suddenly released by the Colts in 2023, leading to his arrival in Philadelphia. Now 29, in theory, Leonard should have plenty of juice left, but he hasn’t been his same elite self since his back surgery. Yet, he may be the best option Buffalo has, and the chance to play for a playoff contender again could be just what he needs to return to being the “Maniac.”
- Shaquille Leonard stats: 88 tackles, 1 sack
- Shaquille Leonard PFF grades: 62.8, 66.9 run defense, 64.3 pass rush, 55.9 coverage
Related: Josh Allen’s MVP odds for 2024-25 season