With The Judgment Day seemingly at a critical point in its evolution, the faction on WWE Raw could be poised for intriguing new additions, ranging from NXT call-ups to established main roster talent. These new members could be brought in to serve as hired muscle or to expand the faction’s influence over major championship storylines.
With that in mind, here are five WWE stars who could join The Judgment Day soon.
Oba Femi
One NXT recruit who possesses the stature to immediately join the main roster in a prominent role is Oba Femi. While “The Ruler” had impressive runs with both the NXT North American Championship and the NXT Championship, he continues to challenge Ricky Saints for the latter title. Femi could be waiting for the right storyline to graduate to the main roster, potentially arriving in The Judgment Day as a hired hand for Dominik Mysterio.
Given that Dominik Mysterio recently reclaimed the Intercontinental Championship at Survivor Series 2025, he may feel compelled to purchase an insurance policy from NXT to secure his title.
Austin Theory
The returning Austin Theory is another potential new member of The Judgment Day. Theory was initially expected to be part of the heel side of the Men’s WarGames match at Survivor Series, but Seth Rollins’ injury intervened, reportedly leading to Theory being removed from the match. He is rumored to be the mystery man who attacked CM Punk at Survivor Series.
Santos Escobar
A potential addition to The Judgment Day is Santos Escobar, a superstar who already has a negative history with Dominik Mysterio’s father, Rey Mysterio. Escobar recently made headlines after his contract briefly expired, but he eventually re-signed with WWE, accepting an improved deal.
Reportedly set to move from SmackDown to Raw and begin competing in singles action, Escobar joining The Judgment Day could lead to future showdowns between him and the elder Rey Mysterio, further fueling the inevitable Father vs. Son rivalry between Rey and Dominik.
Trick Williams
One potential call-up from NXT who could join forces with The Judgment Day is Trick Williams. As a two-time former NXT Champion and a former TNA Wrestling World Champion, Williams is a viable recruit who would be welcomed into the faction. Ultimately, however, Williams may conclude that being part of a larger stable is not his goal.
This potential short-term alliance could eventually lead to an on-screen reunion between Williams and Carmelo Hayes as babyfaces, resulting in a powerful and memorable storyline.
Tony D’Angelo
Tony D’Angelo, a prominent NXT star, has been off television since July, when a cliffhanger segment was used to write him off the show. In the sequence, D’Angelo was seen seated at his favorite restaurant in an apparent homage to the controversial series finale of The Sopranos, looking up at an unknown subject as the show abruptly cut to black.
Tony D’Angelo could be “resurrected” on the main roster as an addition to The Judgment Day, bringing valuable underworld resources to the faction as an ideal recruit.
