Syndication: The Indianapolis Star
Credit: Grace Smith/IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Caitlin Clark reminded everyone why she’s the biggest draw in women’s basketball Thursday night, dropping a team-high 21 points before a scary collision sent her to the bench early in the Indiana Fever’s preseason loss to the Dallas Wings.

The superstar guard stepped back for a three, landed on Alanna Smith’s foot, and went down hard, banging her kneecap on the court. She finished 11-of-13 from the free-throw line for the night.

Afterward, the officials reviewed the play and slapped Smith with a Flagrant 1 for failing to give her landing space. Clark hobbled off but, thankfully, avoided anything serious in what’s become an all-too-familiar scene for the Fever’s franchise player.

Officiating Scrutiny Intensifies After Clark’s Hard Fall and 13 Free Throws

The question here is — Why is this happening? Look, I’m not even faulting the flagrant foul because it’s a play made in response to a basketball move. But why is Clark, who missed a vast majority of her sophomore campaign, getting fouled to the point where she’s taking 13 free throws … in a pre-season game?

It’s absurd.

Clark’s been through the injury wringer already, and now we’re watching defenders land under her jumpers in preseason while she’s sent to the stripe more than any other player in this game. She had nearly twice as many free-throw attempts as the next highest player.

The flagrant call was the right one on review, but it highlights the physical toll Clark absorbs every time she steps on the floor. Whether it’s honest basketball plays or targeted hacks, the star treatment — or lack thereof — keeps fueling the debate over whether the WNBA properly protects its biggest ratings machine.

For her part, Clark insists that the officiating crew did a good job.

“I feel good. I just landed on my kneecap really hard,” she told reporters after the game. “I know there’s a committee of people that really wanted them [the refs] to start calling things, and I thought they did a great job of that.”

“Honestly, I thought the refs were great, and it’s preseason, so you’re probably going to see more fouls called. I expect that number to drop. But I think overall, it’s going to improve the product.”

If it’s not the officiating, then why are players hacking away at her in a meaningless contest? Again, that’s 13 free throws, and she left in the third quarter as a precaution due to the injury.

With the regular season right around the corner, the Fever have to be relieved that Clark walked away from this one relatively unscathed. That said, she’s far too valuable to risk in this manner on sloppy preseason nights. They should know this.

If Clark stays healthy and keeps lighting it up like this, the WNBA’s popularity surge might have some level of legitimate staying power. But these hard fouls and high foul-drawing nights need watching — nobody wants to see the league’s face get dinged up before the real games even start.

avatar
Rusty Weiss is a lifelong Los Angeles Dodgers, Dallas Cowboys, and Xavier Musketeers fan. He has been writing professionally ... More about Rusty Weiss